The Talent Scout Episode 18: When to work with Recruitment Companies

Listen now 

Imagine this scenario, you have a friend and they’ve come to you with a great idea to start up a business or organise a community event. You run through the plans with them and to your horror, you become increasingly aware that they are going to cover everything from sales to accounting to marketing. That sounds like a mess to me, and if it doesn’t horrify you it should.

No one person has the skills needed to span so many aspects of the business world and pull them off successfully. We can all probably do a lot of things well, some things passably, and some things horribly. But we often don’t try to be both a salesperson and an accountant at the same time because most of us are self-aware enough to know which role will suit our skills best. 

Specialisation in recruitment

The same principles hold true for the world of recruitment. Many people think that recruitment is easy, firstly they are wrong. It’s easy to put a body in a role. It is much harder to successfully put someone into a role who is going to drive your organisation forward because ultimately that’s what successful recruitment is all about.

That said, a lot of people end up recruiting for open roles within their organisation when it’s not something that they are trained for, and it’s not something that they’re passionate about. So many HR professionals are actively recruiting when recruitment is not something they’re overly interested in and they would instead much rather devout their time to labour relations and employee engagement.

If we’re willing to accept that it’s something of a ridiculous notion that someone might effectively carry out customer service, marketing, and accounting functions all at the same time, then why do we think it’s acceptable to allow the recruitment within our organisations to be managed by someone who has no recruiting experience or no interest in recruitment?

Recruitment within an organisation is a function that can often hide behind smoke and mirrors. If open roles are getting filled in a timely manner then most people won’t probe too deeply into how their recruitment function is actually operating. However, successful recruitment dictates who becomes a part of your team and overtime how successful that team is.

This means the successes or failures of your people should be the metric used to measure successful recruitment. What I’m trying to get at with this now long-winded analogy is that if you’re trying to figure out how successful your recruitment efforts are then you need to ask yourself a couple of questions. 

How to know if your recruitment is successful

  • How many people that we hire leave during their probation or onboarding period (If this number is high then there is something wrong with your recruitment process).
  • How long does it take for a role to be filled? (If this is greater than 60 days then whoever is recruiting for you might have a skills gap when it comes to candidate attraction, or they just may not have the time needed to keep people engaged in your company during a recruitment timeline. 

If you’re having trouble in either of those areas then is time to dedicate a resource to recruitment. This leaves you with the choice of either hiring a talent-focused resource that can be expensive or working with an external recruitment agency on a cheaper more transactional basis. 

It should be noted that if you already have a dedicated recruitment resource within your organisation you still might need the assistance of an external agency. Recruitment is a time-intensive undertaking and if you have a number of open roles your recruitment team may just be spread a little bit too thin.

Is it the right time to work with a Recruitment Company?

When it comes to working with a recruitment company in most cases you’ll need to haggle over the price that you pay, which is often a percentage of the salary of the individual you’re looking to hire. However, here at Scout Talent we offer an upfront flat fee of $4000 to $8000 which does make us something of a cheaper option. Once pricing has been agreed the recruitment agency will get to work trying to outline your needs and then finding individuals who meet them.

At this point, I want to go back to the professional analogy from earlier. Recruitment agencies are made up of people who are spending most of their week finding highly skilled candidates for the roles of their clients; there are no other distractions or competing priorities other than good recruitment. We know how to find quality candidates, we know how to engage these candidates to consider a new role, we have the time needed to manage interested candidates, and not to sound too cocky – we’re good at it. 

I’m not going to say that using a recruitment agency is what everyone should be doing right now to fill every single one of their roles, because that’s simply not true. But if you are having consistent issues with the people who are making up your team or even struggling to find people in the first place then it might be time to try something new.

It’s madness to keep doing the same thing over and over again and expect a different outcome. 

If you would like to know more about how Scout Talent’s video interview product, call us on 07 3330 2595 or click the button below.

Find out more 

 

Related posts

The McQuaig Job Survey: The 15-Minute Step That Makes Every Hire More Accurate

Tags
Share this blog
Sign up for our newsletter

Receive the latest industry news, exclusive event invites, and useful content straight to your inbox.

Related posts

The McQuaig Job Survey: The 15-Minute Step That Makes Every Hire More Accurate

10 Skills That Separate Great In-House Recruiters From Average Ones

AI in Talent Acquisition: A 6-Step Framework for Going AI-Native

Why Choose Scout Talent

“I’m aware of the silly tricks that those in the industry play, which is why we use Scout Talent instead of an agency! We’ve actually done A/B testing on Scout Talent vs a recruiter, and the quality was chalk and cheese- no kidding, you can quote me.”

– Melissa Kirby
Sharpe and Abel

Our Total Talent Acquisition Software

Recruitment Campaign Services
The right mix of expertise, structure, and care, our recruitment campaigns make hiring faster, easier, and more cost-effective

Employer Branding
Position your company as an employer of choice with a strong employer brand

Employee Engagement Surveys
Gain insights on how your people feel at work so you can boost performance, retention, and culture

Recruitment Process Outsourcing
Expert recruiters and proven processes to hire top talent efficiently and more cost-effectively

Learning Services
We design customised digital training, delivered through a powerful LMS that streamlines, tracks, and measures learning—building skills and boosting performance.

Key Benefits

Expert-led campaigns crafted with strategy and care to connect you with the right people quickly, easily and cost-effectively.
Combine authentic employer branding with engagement insights to create workplaces where top talent wants to belong and stay.
Access seasoned recruiters who work inside your business—bringing flexibility and proven processes without the cost or risk of extra headcount.
Show candidates and employees you invest in their future with development pathways that make your organisation a magnet for great people.
Why Choose Scout Talent

“I’ve been a user of Scout’s software for many years, working with both the full enterprise solution :Recruit and the lite :Essentials platform. I appreciate that Scout offers fit-for-purpose options to suit different business needs.



Scout’s ATS has been instrumental in driving efficiency and productivity. In a previous project …This transformation saved our team significant time… and eliminated room for error with its intuitive workflow and transparent features.



It’s a fantastic product, and we couldn’t be happier with the results.”

– Wendy Woodford
People and Culture Manager
Housing Trust

Our Total Talent Acquisition Software

:Recruit
Your AI-powered total talent acquisition ATS and CRM solution

:Recruit Essentials
Your AI-powered Lite version of :Recruit tailored for small organisations

:Onboard
Your digital contract creation

:Recruit Pro
Your AI-powered :Recruit + :Onboard, backed by human expertise, tools, analytics, and specialist support

:Engage
Your recruitment marketing and candidate pooling platform

Scout Learning
Your customisable LMS with specialist support

Scout Talent App
Your mobile application helping you hire on the go

Felix
Your AI-powered talent acquisition assistant

Key Features

Post once, publish everywhere, and track candidates from application to hire in a single platform.

Leverage AI to screen faster, uncover hidden talent, and craft compelling job ads that attract the right candidates.

Make confident hiring decisions with dashboards that highlight pipeline health, recruiter performance, and ROI.

Connect with job boards, HRIS, payroll, and more, keeping your recruitment process fluid and connected.