The Talent Scout Episode 5: What Does Good Headhunting Look Like?

Here at Scout we know that recruitment is extremely hard. Headhunting in particular, is probably one of the hardest and most time-consuming types of recruitment you can undertake. Which probably begs the question of why do we do it?

Well, let’s back up a few minutes.

Traditionally, recruiters used to look at the talent pool as being made up of passive and active candidates. Active being those that are actively looking at job boards and applying for jobs and passive being the group that are not actively looking but would be open to a new role if it were the right fit and it was presented to them.

We now have come to the point of continual candidates.

There was once a time when people would see a role and company as the place the would work for life. Those days are mostly now a thing of the past. Employees now have an eye on the door at all times to ensure that they don’t miss out on their next big opportunity. Millennials in particular as a group have a tendency to prefer to advance their career by moving to a different organization rather than wait for opportunities for promotion to open up where they are. By 2025, millennials will make up 75% of the global workforce.

Depending on where you are or who you are this all might terrify you. But it’s also an opportunity, and that’s where we come to headhunting. With so much of the current workforce open to new opportunities once they are presented to them, headhunting is suddenly an extremely valuable tool in your recruitment arsenal!

Headhunting can take many forms, it can be online and high tech, using tools like LinkedIn’s recruiter license or Indeed’s Resume search function or whichever organization has the biggest database of resumes and CVs where you are located. It can also be offline and really effective. Of course, it can also be offline and really creepy and ineffective too. Don’t be one of those people that approaches someone in their place of work, in front of their boss, and tries to offer them a new role. That’s about as useful as yelling at strangers in a park that you have an opening for a new role.

Online Headhunting

Let’s look at the online world first. Effective recruitment here can be quite time consuming and may take a lot of effort to yield results, but there are certain ways to bolster your chances when reviewing an online database or reaching out to people on LinkedIn.

Some recruiters like to spam hundreds of profiles with a message that barely describes the role and is clearly mass-produced. This is useless. If by some miracle it garners you a hire, it will not be the best hire you could get. You need to take time to read the information that the person you’re interested in has on their profile and tailor your message towards them. If there’s something particular in their experience you’re interested in, highlight that to them, and in doing so make it clear that your message isn’t mass-produced and is instead solely for you.

On the back of that be prepared that your candidate has all of the power, you can’t hide things like salary range from them, you can’t get them to bend over backwards and answer hundreds of screening questions. You’ve reached out to them which means you need to meet them where they are, maybe it’s an initial casual phone call so they can ask some questions, maybe it’s a visit to your office, maybe they’ll be interested straight away and ready for an interview. Who knows, but one thing is for certain, they’re not going to fall into a strict recruitment process. Allow some wiggle room for them, they are potentially your purple unicorn after all. Cater to their needs as much as possible because remember they did not seek you out, you sought them out.

Online recruitment tools can be expensive and if you’re not recruiting frequently you may want to reach out to an external company such as ourselves for support on that front.

However, there are other options for you. Offline headhunting can be really powerful and even if it doesn’t make you that initial hire it can be really effective at bolstering your employer brand.

Offline Headhunting

There is a multitude of different ways you can go about Offline Headhunting. The easiest is an employee referral program. Tell your employees which roles you’re struggling to fill and reward them for finding someone who lasts in the role. Your employees know people in their field and probably have quite a large reach to potential candidates you’re not aware of. If you’re not able to reward your employees with some monetary increases there are other options open to you. An example from a client we work with was to buy a holiday for two for one of their employees each year, to be in the running you had to have referred an employee to the organization that lasted a certain period of time and at the end of the year, all the employees that had referred someone were put into a raffle and a random winner was selected. Something creative like that can sometimes appeal to your workforce more than a short-lived monetary gain.

Employee Referral Programs are of course not your only option. Lots of organizations have had great success by hosting some sort of networking event. The easiest example is to get an interesting guest speaker, bonus points if they appeal to your target demographic, and open your office up to the public. Before the speaker begins, have your open roles clearly visible on fliers or on a projector and again do the same when your speaker finishes. It’s incredibly effective because essentially, you’re selling your organization to people by saying ‘look how great we are, we even have this person as a guest speaker’, while also trying to recruit them with your open roles.

Whatever you decide to do and whichever avenue you choose to take, you do need to mentally prepare yourself for the fact that headhunting will take time. No one makes a begin decision like a career move in an instant. So take a breath, prepare yourself for the long recruitment process, and buy your employees a couple of trips to Hawaii.

For more information, get in touch with the Scout Talent team on 07 3330 2595 or at info@scouttalent.com.au.

Related posts

The McQuaig Job Survey: The 15-Minute Step That Makes Every Hire More Accurate

Tags
Share this blog
Sign up for our newsletter

Receive the latest industry news, exclusive event invites, and useful content straight to your inbox.

Related posts

The McQuaig Job Survey: The 15-Minute Step That Makes Every Hire More Accurate

10 Skills That Separate Great In-House Recruiters From Average Ones

AI in Talent Acquisition: A 6-Step Framework for Going AI-Native

Why Choose Scout Talent

“I’m aware of the silly tricks that those in the industry play, which is why we use Scout Talent instead of an agency! We’ve actually done A/B testing on Scout Talent vs a recruiter, and the quality was chalk and cheese- no kidding, you can quote me.”

– Melissa Kirby
Sharpe and Abel

Our Total Talent Acquisition Software

Recruitment Campaign Services
The right mix of expertise, structure, and care, our recruitment campaigns make hiring faster, easier, and more cost-effective

Employer Branding
Position your company as an employer of choice with a strong employer brand

Employee Engagement Surveys
Gain insights on how your people feel at work so you can boost performance, retention, and culture

Recruitment Process Outsourcing
Expert recruiters and proven processes to hire top talent efficiently and more cost-effectively

Learning Services
We design customised digital training, delivered through a powerful LMS that streamlines, tracks, and measures learning—building skills and boosting performance.

Key Benefits

Expert-led campaigns crafted with strategy and care to connect you with the right people quickly, easily and cost-effectively.
Combine authentic employer branding with engagement insights to create workplaces where top talent wants to belong and stay.
Access seasoned recruiters who work inside your business—bringing flexibility and proven processes without the cost or risk of extra headcount.
Show candidates and employees you invest in their future with development pathways that make your organisation a magnet for great people.
Why Choose Scout Talent

“I’ve been a user of Scout’s software for many years, working with both the full enterprise solution :Recruit and the lite :Essentials platform. I appreciate that Scout offers fit-for-purpose options to suit different business needs.



Scout’s ATS has been instrumental in driving efficiency and productivity. In a previous project …This transformation saved our team significant time… and eliminated room for error with its intuitive workflow and transparent features.



It’s a fantastic product, and we couldn’t be happier with the results.”

– Wendy Woodford
People and Culture Manager
Housing Trust

Our Total Talent Acquisition Software

:Recruit
Your AI-powered total talent acquisition ATS and CRM solution

:Recruit Essentials
Your AI-powered Lite version of :Recruit tailored for small organisations

:Onboard
Your digital contract creation

:Recruit Pro
Your AI-powered :Recruit + :Onboard, backed by human expertise, tools, analytics, and specialist support

:Engage
Your recruitment marketing and candidate pooling platform

Scout Learning
Your customisable LMS with specialist support

Scout Talent App
Your mobile application helping you hire on the go

Felix
Your AI-powered talent acquisition assistant

Key Features

Post once, publish everywhere, and track candidates from application to hire in a single platform.

Leverage AI to screen faster, uncover hidden talent, and craft compelling job ads that attract the right candidates.

Make confident hiring decisions with dashboards that highlight pipeline health, recruiter performance, and ROI.

Connect with job boards, HRIS, payroll, and more, keeping your recruitment process fluid and connected.