Converting Candidates to Hires: How to Get to “Yes” Faster

It’s so exciting when you find a fantastic candidate who you know will add value to your organisation. But what if they’re reluctant to come on board? Follow these strategies to win them over.  

The success of your organisation rests on your ability to attract, identify, and onboard top talent. Is your hiring and onboarding process running as smoothly as it could be?

You don’t want to waste time with long, drawn-out negotiations when you needed someone to start yesterday. Use these tips to convert “maybes” to “yes!”.

Be prepared

When engaging with candidates, it’s important to be prepared, and this means doing your research. Don’t lose great talent by offering salaries that are too low or incentives that are unachievable.

While some candidates may propose a counter-offer, others will simply walk away. Worse yet, some may walk away and tell others about how low the offer was, making it hard for you to continue recruiting.

Research the remuneration and offering for similar positions in your area. This is especially important if this is a new position in your company, or you are replacing a long-time employee. Many employees consider perks such as flexible hours or professional development to be part of their offer package. Make sure to research perks and benefits as well as salaries.

Have a strong employer brand

Candidates use on average up to 18 sources to research a potential organisation before making the decision to join. What does your employer brand look like in the market?

By the time you make an offer, the candidate should already know the company’s story. Not just your history, but the story that makes the candidate want to work for you. Let’s say you describe your company as a place that manufactures parts for cars. That’s a description, but your company’s story is that you make essential components of the safest automobiles on the market today. You provide a safe work environment dedicated to the well-being and professional growth of your employees.

A strong employer brand involves storytelling, which helps candidates understand why they want to work for you.

Think win/win

You should not only assess what your candidate can bring to your organisation, but what you can offer them. Every point of engagement, including negotiations, are part of your ongoing relationship and employer brand.

This makes it important that you think of your negotiations not as a situation where one of you will win and one will lose, but as a situation where both people get what they need to start a productive relationship.

Listen actively

Demonstrate to your candidates that you genuinely care about them through active listening. Understand any concerns they might have and address them with positive, mutually beneficial solutions.

For example, if your candidate tells you that he or she needs more money to offset the travel costs of taking a position farther from his or her house you could respond with, “I understand our location is a concern for you. Would working a different schedule so you can avoid rush hour, or having one day a week to work at home help with those concerns?” By listening to what the candidate is actually concerned about, you may be able to find a solution that doesn’t involve more money.

Know exactly what you can offer

Don’t delay onboarding a great new hire by wasting time needed sign-off and approval for salary and benefits.

Before making an offer to a promising candidate make sure to have any necessary internal discussions about how high the salary can go or other benefits such as working remotely, additional vacation days, or flexible hours. There may be some requests or situations that the hiring manager does not feel comfortable agreeing to without more discussion, but try to keep the back and forth to a minimum. You want to avoid any situation where the candidate feels the hiring manager is at odds with someone else in the company.

While there may be some situations you won’t be able to overcome, such as differing timelines, these strategies to keep your hiring process efficient and help you win candidates over when they have competing offers.

Related posts

The Job Survey: The 15-Minute Step That Makes Every Hire More Accurate

Tags
Share this blog
Sign up for our newsletter

Receive the latest industry news, exclusive event invites, and useful content straight to your inbox.

Related posts

The Job Survey: The 15-Minute Step That Makes Every Hire More Accurate

10 Skills That Separate Great In-House Recruiters From Average Ones

AI in Talent Acquisition: A 6-Step Framework for Going AI-Native

Why Choose Scout Talent

“I’m aware of the silly tricks that those in the industry play, which is why we use Scout Talent instead of an agency! We’ve actually done A/B testing on Scout Talent vs a recruiter, and the quality was chalk and cheese- no kidding, you can quote me.”

– Melissa Kirby
Sharpe and Abel

Our Total Talent Acquisition Software

Recruitment Campaign Services
The right mix of expertise, structure, and care, our recruitment campaigns make hiring faster, easier, and more cost-effective

Employer Branding
Position your company as an employer of choice with a strong employer brand

Employee Engagement Surveys
Gain insights on how your people feel at work so you can boost performance, retention, and culture

Recruitment Process Outsourcing
Expert recruiters and proven processes to hire top talent efficiently and more cost-effectively

Learning Services
We design customised digital training, delivered through a powerful LMS that streamlines, tracks, and measures learning—building skills and boosting performance.

Key Benefits

Expert-led campaigns crafted with strategy and care to connect you with the right people quickly, easily and cost-effectively.
Combine authentic employer branding with engagement insights to create workplaces where top talent wants to belong and stay.
Access seasoned recruiters who work inside your business—bringing flexibility and proven processes without the cost or risk of extra headcount.
Show candidates and employees you invest in their future with development pathways that make your organisation a magnet for great people.
Why Choose Scout Talent

“I’ve been a user of Scout’s software for many years, working with both the full enterprise solution :Recruit and the lite :Essentials platform. I appreciate that Scout offers fit-for-purpose options to suit different business needs.



Scout’s ATS has been instrumental in driving efficiency and productivity. In a previous project …This transformation saved our team significant time… and eliminated room for error with its intuitive workflow and transparent features.



It’s a fantastic product, and we couldn’t be happier with the results.”

– Wendy Woodford
People and Culture Manager
Housing Trust

Our Total Talent Acquisition Software

:Recruit
Your AI-powered total talent acquisition ATS and CRM solution

:Recruit Essentials
Your AI-powered Lite version of :Recruit tailored for small organisations

:Onboard
Your digital contract creation

:Recruit Pro
Your AI-powered :Recruit + :Onboard, backed by human expertise, tools, analytics, and specialist support

:Engage
Your recruitment marketing and candidate pooling platform

Scout Learning
Your customisable LMS with specialist support

Scout Talent App
Your mobile application helping you hire on the go

Felix
Your AI-powered talent acquisition assistant

Key Features

Post once, publish everywhere, and track candidates from application to hire in a single platform.

Leverage AI to screen faster, uncover hidden talent, and craft compelling job ads that attract the right candidates.

Make confident hiring decisions with dashboards that highlight pipeline health, recruiter performance, and ROI.

Connect with job boards, HRIS, payroll, and more, keeping your recruitment process fluid and connected.